Blog

Landmark Supreme Court Ruling Recognizes Polyamorous Relationships in Property Disputes

In a groundbreaking decision, the Supreme Court has recently ruled that an ex-polyamorous relationship is entitled to a fair share of their former $2 million property in Kumeū, Auckland. The case revolves around Brett Paul, his ex-wife Lilach Paul, and Fiona Mead, who were involved in a 15-year relationship. The trio resided together on the Kumeū farm, which was purchased by Mead and registered under her name. Following the breakup of Lilach with Brett and later Mead with Brett, a legal battle ensued, leading to a significant legal precedent for polyamorous relationships in property disputes.

On Tuesday, the Supreme Court announced its decision, granting equal claim to the relationship property for all three members involved, a right traditionally reserved for legally married or de facto couples. Auckland University’s family law Professor Mark Henaghan explained that the Court of Appeal and the majority of the Supreme Court considered the trio as a series of couples while living together as a throuple. According to Professor Henaghan, this ruling sets a precedent that extends the protection and entitlements of the Property (Relationships) Act to individuals in similar living arrangements.

Professor Henaghan emphasized that the Property (Relationships) Act is built on the concept that once you enter into a relationship, you share both the risks and rewards. The court recognized that the trio formed a series of couples within their polyamorous relationship: Lilach and Greg were in a married relationship, Fiona and Lilach were in a de facto relationship, and Fiona and Greg were also in a de facto relationship. This finding reinforces the argument that living arrangements involving committed relationships should be considered as a form of family relationship, allowing equal property sharing under the act.

In the wake of this Supreme Court ruling recognising the rights of a polyamorous relationship, it becomes pertinent to explore the significance of prenups to contract out of such rights. Prenups can be valuable for polyamorous couples, offering them legal protection, certainty, and the ability to tailor their property arrangements according to their unique dynamics.

CUSTOMIZATION TO INDIVIDUAL NEEDS: Polyamorous relationships often involve complex dynamics and varied financial arrangements. By entering into a prenup, throuples have the opportunity to customize their property arrangements to align with their specific needs and preferences. This allows them to define how assets and liabilities will be divided, taking into account individual contributions, personal circumstances, and the intricacies of their relationships. The ability to tailor property agreements provides a sense of control and ensures that the arrangement reflects the realities of their unique situation.

PROTECTION OF PERSONAL ASSETS: a prenup offers a valuable safeguard for polyamorous individuals who may have pre-existing assets or property they wish to protect. Through a clear and legally binding agreement, each party can delineate their separate property and establish its exclusion from relationship property claims. This protection extends to assets acquired before the relationship or acquired through inheritance or personal endeavours, providing peace of mind and reducing the risk of disputes or unfair outcomes

CLARITY AND CERTAINTY: One of the primary benefits of a prenup is the clarity and certainty it brings to the financial aspects of a polyamorous relationship. By clearly defining the ownership, division, and distribution of assets, throuples can mitigate potential conflicts and disputes that may arise in the future. This promotes a healthier and more stable relationship by providing a transparent framework for managing property matters, reducing ambiguity and the likelihood of misunderstandings.

PRESERVING AUTONOMY AND RELATIONSHIPS: In polyamorous relationships, individuals often value their autonomy and the ability to maintain multiple meaningful connections. A prenup can help protect the autonomy and independence of each party by preserving their separate property and financial interests. By clearly defining property rights and responsibilities, throuples can navigate their relationships with greater freedom, knowing that their individual assets and financial well-being are safeguarded.

PRACTICAL CONSIDERATIONS: a prenup also addresses practical considerations, such as business ventures or financial obligations outside the relationship. Polyamorous individuals may have diverse career paths, entrepreneurial endeavours, or financial commitments that require distinct property arrangements. A well-crafted agreement allows throuples to manage these practicalities efficiently, ensuring that the relationship does not hinder individual aspirations or impede external financial responsibilities.

For polyamorous throuples, a prenup offers numerous advantages. By customizing property arrangements, protecting personal assets, ensuring clarity and certainty, preserving autonomy, and addressing practical considerations, these agreements empower throuples to navigate their relationships with confidence and security. As polyamorous relationships gain recognition and acceptance, such agreements become invaluable tools for promoting fairness, stability, and the protection of individual and collective interests within these dynamic and evolving relationship structures.